CompromessoCheckThis is a sample report — produced by our engine from a fictional (but realistic) preliminary contract we wrote for testing. No real buyer, seller or property.
Analyze my documentYour document report
Every quote below is taken verbatim from that sample contract. Your report will look exactly like this, about a minute after payment.
What you're looking at, in plain English
This is a private preliminary contract (compromesso) for the sale of a house with land in Panicale (PG), Umbria, between an Italian seller (Rossi Mario) and a US-resident buyer (John Miller), for €185,000. The buyer has agreed to pay €25,000 now as a "caparra confirmatoria" (a legally significant deposit under art. 1385 c.c.) and the remaining €160,000 at the final notarial deed (rogito), to be signed by 30 November 2026. The document is short and one-sided in several important respects: it gives the seller an explicit right to keep the whole deposit if the buyer fails to show up at the deed, but says nothing about what happens if the seller defaults, contains no financing (mortgage) condition, discloses an unresolved 1995 building amnesty application that was never confirmed as concluded, and reveals the property came to the seller by donation in 2019 — a fact that has real implications under a law that changed very recently. It also commits the buyer to pay a non-refundable 4% agency commission immediately, regardless of whether the sale ever completes. As it stands, this contract leaves the buyer more exposed than would be normal in a balanced, well-drafted Italian preliminary agreement, and several material verifications (cadastral/mortgage searches, condono status, condominium — n/a here — reciprocity, technician's report) appear not yet done or not evidenced in the document itself.
Key terms
| Parties | Seller: Rossi Mario (Italian resident, Perugia); Buyer: John Miller (US citizen, resident in Chicago, IL) | Buyer is a non-EU, non-resident foreign national — condizione di reciprocità applies (art. 16 preleggi). |
| Property | House (piano terra e primo piano) plus ~2,500 sqm of land, Comune di Panicale (PG), Località Colle San Paolo, Via delle Vigne n. 3; Catasto Fabbricati Foglio 27 Part. 154 Sub. 2, Cat. A/3; Catasto Terreni Foglio 27 Part. 155, seminativo | Mixed residential + agricultural land parcel — check if agricultural pre-emption (prelazione agraria) could apply to the land portion. |
| Price | €185,000 total | €25,000 deposit + €160,000 balance at deed. |
| Deposit type | Caparra confirmatoria ex art. 1385 c.c., €25,000 | Legally significant: if buyer defaults, seller may keep it; if seller defaults, buyer could claim double or sue for performance — but as drafted only the seller's remedy is spelled out. |
| Deed deadline | Rogito by 30/11/2026, notary chosen by the seller | Buyer has no say in choice of notary as drafted — unusual to leave this solely to seller. |
| Mortgage condition | None stated | No condizione sospensiva di mutuo — if buyer's financing falls through, buyer risks losing the whole €25,000 deposit. |
| Building compliance | 1995 condono edilizio application (L. 724/1994) for expansion of the first floor, described as still pending ('in corso di definizione') with the Comune | Amnesty not yet granted — buyer could inherit an unresolved planning irregularity. |
| Provenance | Property came to seller via donation (atto di donazione), Notaio Bianchi di Perugia, 15/06/2019 | Donated provenance affects title security for heirs' claims — governed by the recently reformed L. 182/2025 regime. |
| Agency commission | 4% + IVA of sale price, due entirely on signing this preliminary, described as non-refundable even if the deed is never signed | Highly unfavourable to buyer; commission is normally tied to actual conclusion of the deal (artt. 1754-1755 c.c.) and negotiable. |
| Governing jurisdiction | Foro di Perugia (exclusive) | Any dispute must be litigated in Italy, in Perugia. |
What we found
No mortgage (financing) condition — buyer risks losing entire €25,000 deposit if financing fails
The contract does not make the purchase conditional on the buyer obtaining a mortgage (condizione sospensiva di mutuo). If Mr. Miller needs financing and it falls through, under Art. 3 the seller may treat this as a no-show and keep the whole €25,000 caparra confirmatoria (art. 1385 c.c.). This is one of the most common and costly traps for foreign buyers.
“il saldo di Euro 160.000,00 alla stipula dell'atto notarile definitivo.”
→ Before signing, ask that a suspensive clause be added making the deal conditional on mortgage approval within a stated deadline, with the deposit returned if financing is declined.
One-sided default clause: only the buyer's breach is addressed
The contract explicitly spells out the seller's remedy if the buyer fails to appear (keeping the full deposit), but is silent on what happens if the seller fails to appear or otherwise defaults. Under art. 1385 c.c., if the seller is in default the buyer would in principle be entitled to withdraw and claim double the deposit, or to sue for performance under art. 2932 c.c. — but leaving this unstated invites disputes and weakens the buyer's negotiating position.
“In caso di mancata presentazione della parte promissaria acquirente alla data fissata, la parte promittente venditrice avra' facolta' di recedere dal presente contratto trattenendo l'intera caparra versata.”
→ Ask that a mirror clause be added expressly confirming the buyer's right, in case of seller default, to withdraw and receive double the deposit, or to sue for specific performance (art. 1385, 2932 c.c.).
Unresolved 1995 building amnesty (condono edilizio) still pending
An amnesty application on file is not proof the works are actually regularized — it merely started a process that, more than 30 years later, is still open. Until the Comune formally grants the condono, the first-floor extension's legal status is uncertain, which can affect the buyer's ability to obtain a mortgage, to resell, or to avoid later sanctions.
“La parte promittente venditrice dichiara che per il fabbricato e' stata presentata in data 28/02/1995 domanda di condono edilizio ai sensi della Legge 724/1994 relativamente all'ampliamento del piano primo, il cui procedimento risulta ancora in corso di definizione presso il Comune di Panicale.”
→ Have a geometra/technician verify the current status of the condono file with the Comune di Panicale before signing, and confirm the stato legittimo (art. 9-bis DPR 380/2001) of the whole building, not just this extension.
Donated provenance (2019) — reformed legal regime requires careful checking, financing may be affected
The property was acquired by the seller through a donation in 2019. Heirs of the donor who feel shortchanged in their reserved share can, in principle, challenge this. Under the recent reform (L. 182/2025, in force from 18 December 2025, and the transitional window that closed 18 June 2026), such a claim now generally leads to a monetary claim against the donee rather than recovery of the property from a later buyer — so this is not automatically a deal-breaker — but the notary needs to work through the donor's situation (is the donor still alive? are there other heirs? any registered reduction claim or opposition act?), and separately, some banks are still cautious about lending on donated-provenance properties while their internal policies catch up with the reform.
“Dichiara altresi' che l'immobile e' pervenuto alla parte promittente venditrice per atto di donazione a rogito Notaio Bianchi di Perugia in data 15/06/2019, rep. 45.812.”
→ Ask the notary to confirm: whether the donor is alive, who the protected heirs are, whether any azione di riduzione or opposition has been registered, which transitional regime applies, and whether the buyer's mortgage lender has any special requirements for donated-provenance properties.
Non-refundable 4% agency commission due immediately, even if sale falls through
Under artt. 1754-1755 c.c., commission is generally due when the deal is concluded through the agent's involvement; making it fully due and non-refundable at the preliminary stage, regardless of whether the final deed ever happens, is a buyer-unfavourable term that is contractual, not automatic law, and can be negotiated.
“una provvigione del 4% (quattro per cento) oltre IVA sul prezzo di vendita, da corrispondersi integralmente alla sottoscrizione del presente preliminare e non ripetibile in alcun caso, anche di mancata stipula dell'atto definitivo.”
→ Ask the agent/seller whether the commission timing and non-refundability can be renegotiated, e.g. tied to successful completion of the rogito, or partially refundable if the deal fails for reasons outside the buyer's control.
Seller unilaterally chooses the notary
While Italian practice often lets either party propose the notary, and the notary is a neutral public official regardless of who chooses them, giving the seller sole discretion is not the most balanced arrangement and can be adjusted by negotiation.
“L'atto pubblico di compravendita sara' stipulato entro e non oltre il 30/11/2026 presso il Notaio che sara' designato dalla parte promittente venditrice.”
→ Consider asking for a jointly agreed notary, or at least the right to have your own lawyer review the deed draft in advance.
No cadastral/urbanistic conformity declaration beyond the condono mention
Beyond the pending condono, the contract does not include the seller's declaration that the property's actual physical state matches the cadastral plans and data (required at the deed stage under art. 29, comma 1-bis, L. 52/1985), nor any confirmation of agibilità (fitness for use). A 'sold as-is, with all easements' clause is standard boilerplate but should not be read as covering these separate compliance questions.
“L'immobile viene promesso in vendita nello stato di fatto e di diritto in cui si trova, con ogni servitu' attiva e passiva, apparente e non apparente.”
→ Ask for written confirmation of cadastral conformity and agibilità status before the deed, and have a technician check for other undeclared discrepancies.
Agricultural land portion may attract pre-emption rights
The sale includes land classified as seminativo (arable). Depending on how the land is used and by whom, neighbouring farmers or tenant cultivators may hold a prelazione agraria (right of first refusal) under art. 8 L. 590/1965, which if applicable could unwind or complicate the sale.
“al Catasto Terreni al Foglio 27, Particella 155, qualita' seminativo, classe 3.”
→ Ask the notary to confirm whether prelazione agraria applies to Particella 155 and what steps (if any) have been or need to be taken (e.g. formal notice to potential holders).
No mention of trascrizione (registration in the land registers) of this preliminary contract
The document does not mention having this preliminary contract trascritto (registered in the public land registers) under art. 2645-bis c.c., which would protect the buyer against later sales, mortgages or liens registered by the seller before the final deed. This point is not stated in the document at all.
→ Ask the notary whether trascrizione of this preliminary is advisable given the roughly 4-month gap until the scheduled rogito, and what it would cost.
Reciprocity condition and codice fiscale for the US buyer
As a non-EU, non-resident buyer, Mr. Miller's right to buy is subject to the condizione di reciprocità (art. 16 disp. prel. c.c.). Reciprocity is well-established practice for US citizens, but the notary must confirm it case by case. The document shows a codice fiscale already obtained, which is required to sign the deed.
“Mr. JOHN MILLER, nato a Chicago (USA) il 22/07/1971, C.F. MLLJHN71L22Z404Q”
→ Ask the notary to confirm reciprocity is satisfied for a US citizen and that the codice fiscale shown is valid and correctly registered.
Language of the contract — no interpreter or bilingual text provided
The preliminary contract is entirely in Italian, and there is no indication of a bilingual version or sworn interpreter having been used, though this document is a private scrittura privata, not the final public deed where this requirement is legally mandated (artt. 54-55 L. 89/1913) if a party does not understand Italian.
→ Confirm the buyer fully understands the Italian text (ideally via an independent certified translation) and ensure a bilingual text or sworn interpreter is arranged for the final notarial deed if needed.
Protections you don't have (yet)
Things a well-advised buyer would normally have in this document — and this one doesn't.
No suspensive condition for mortgage approval
A well-advised buyer relying on financing would normally have the purchase made conditional on loan approval, with the deposit protected if the loan is refused. This contract has no such clause.
→ Request this be added before signing, or before making any further payment.
No reciprocal default/remedy clause for the seller
Standard balanced preliminari spell out the buyer's remedies (double deposit or specific performance) if the seller defaults; here only the seller's remedy against the buyer is stated.
→ Request an explicit mirror clause covering seller default.
No provision for notary escrow of the balance (deposito prezzo presso il notaio)
Given the open condono and donated provenance, this is a case where holding the €160,000 balance with the notary until registrations are checked (art. 1, commi 63-67, L. 147/2013) would meaningfully reduce the buyer's risk.
→ Ask that the preliminary or the deed provide for this escrow mechanism.
No visura ipotecaria/catastale results referenced or attached
The contract asserts the property will arrive free of liens but does not reference an actual mortgage/land registry search (visura ipotecaria) or up-to-date cadastral visura performed and attached.
→ Request copies of a current visura ipotecaria and visura catastale before proceeding.
No APE (energy certificate) referenced
The document does not mention the Attestato di Prestazione Energetica, which is mandatory and must be delivered to the buyer and attached at the deed.
→ Ask for the APE now, before the deed.
Ask the notary
- Can you confirm the current status of the 28/02/1995 condono edilizio application (L. 724/1994) for the first-floor extension — has it been granted, refused, or is it still pending, and what does that mean for the stato legittimo of the building?
- Given the property came to the seller by donation in 2019, can you confirm the donor's situation, whether any azione di riduzione or opposition has been registered, and which regime (old or the L. 182/2025 reform) applies to this case?
- Is the condizione di reciprocità satisfied for a US citizen buyer, and is the codice fiscale shown (MLLJHN71L22Z404Q) valid and properly registered?
- Should this preliminary contract be trascritto in the land registers (art. 2645-bis c.c.) given the roughly four-month gap before the scheduled rogito, and what would that cost?
- Can the balance of €160,000 be held in escrow via the notary's deposito prezzo mechanism (L. 147/2013) rather than paid directly to the seller at the deed?
- Does the seminativo land (Particella 155) trigger any prelazione agraria rights for neighbouring farmers or tenants?
- Has a current visura ipotecaria been pulled to confirm the property is genuinely free of mortgages, liens, or prejudicial registrations?
- Is an APE (energy performance certificate) available, and will it be attached to the final deed?
Ask the agent / seller
- Can the 4% + IVA commission be made contingent on the deed actually being completed, rather than fully due and non-refundable on signing this preliminary?
- Why is there no suspensive clause for mortgage financing in this contract, and would the seller agree to add one?
- Can you provide documentation on the current status of the 1995 condono application with the Comune di Panicale?
- Can the buyer have input into the choice of notary rather than it being solely the seller's designation?
- Is there a technician's report (relazione tecnica) available confirming the cadastral and urbanistic conformity of the property, including the first-floor extension?
Our honest take: bring in a lawyer
This preliminary contract combines several materially important, unresolved issues for a foreign buyer: an open building amnesty from 1995 with no confirmed resolution, a donated provenance that intersects with a very recently reformed area of Italian succession law, the total absence of a mortgage financing condition, and a one-sided default clause. Given the deposit at risk (€25,000) and the complexity of verifying the condono and donation history properly, an independent Italian real-estate lawyer (and a technician/geometra) should review the file and the underlying municipal and land registry records before the buyer pays the deposit or signs.
Glossary
- Caparra confirmatoria
- — A deposit under art. 1385 c.c. that gives the non-defaulting party the option, if the other side breaches, to withdraw and keep the deposit (or claim double it back if the seller defaulted) — or instead to sue for damages or completion of the sale.
- Condono edilizio
- — An extraordinary building amnesty allowed only under specific historic laws (1985, 1994, 2003) for works built without the required permits, requiring a formal application and grant by the municipality.
- Rogito notarile
- — The final notarial deed of sale, signed before a notary, which actually transfers ownership (as opposed to the preliminary contract, which only creates an obligation to sell/buy).
- Trascrizione
- — Registration of a deed or contract in the public land registers, which — unlike simple tax registration — gives legal priority against later competing claims on the property.
- Condizione sospensiva
- — A suspensive condition making the contract's effects depend on a future event, such as mortgage approval.
- Prelazione agraria
- — A statutory right of first refusal that certain neighbouring farmers or tenant cultivators may have when agricultural land is sold.
- Stato legittimo
- — The proven lawful planning status of a building, established through its original permit plus the permits for its last works, as required under art. 9-bis DPR 380/2001.
- Condizione di reciprocità
- — A requirement under art. 16 preleggi that non-EU, non-resident foreign buyers can only buy property in Italy if their home country grants equivalent rights to Italian citizens — established practice for US, UK, Canadian and Australian citizens, but the notary confirms it case by case.
Legal checklist verified current as of 2026-08-17. Italian property law changes: we review the rules behind this analysis on a schedule and update them when they move. This report is an automated, educational analysis of the document you uploaded. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer-client relationship. Verify important points with a notary or an independent lawyer before signing.
This report would have saved this buyer from three expensive surprises.
Get the same analysis for your document — in about a minute.
Analyze my document — from $39