Caparra confirmatoria vs caparra penitenziale: what your Italian deposit really means

Caparra confirmatoria (art. 1385 c.c.) — the standard, and the toughest

This is what you'll find in the vast majority of Italian preliminary contracts. If the buyer fails to complete the purchase, the seller keeps the entire deposit. If the seller fails, the buyer is entitled to twice the deposit back. Alternatively, either side can go to court to force the actual completion of the sale (esecuzione in forma specifica, art. 2932 c.c.).

There is no cooling-off period and no exceptions for changed circumstances. A refused mortgage, a job loss, a divorce — none of it saves your deposit unless the contract contains a clause saying so.

Caparra penitenziale (art. 1386 c.c.) — the price of walking away

Rarer. Here the deposit is the agreed price of the right to withdraw: either party can walk away by forfeiting it (or paying double, if it's the seller), and that's the end of it — no lawsuits, no forced completion. It gives both sides a clean exit, which is exactly why sellers seldom offer it.

Acconto — just an advance payment

An acconto is a simple advance on the price, with no penalty function. If the deal collapses, it must in principle be returned, and ordinary contract-breach rules apply. It sounds safer for the buyer — but it also gives the seller weaker reasons to stay committed, and pure-acconto arrangements are uncommon in practice.

The trap: the word decides, not your intention

Italian courts look at what the contract says. If it says 'a titolo di caparra confirmatoria ai sensi dell'art. 1385 c.c.', that's what you signed — whatever the agent told you verbally. And when a contract is ambiguous about the deposit's nature, litigation is slow and expensive. If the wording in your draft is unclear, that is itself a red flag worth raising before signing.

One more thing: the deposit's protection is only as good as the rest of the contract. A caparra with no mortgage condition means your deposit is exposed to your bank's decision. Check both together.

Check your contract in 60 seconds

Our analysis reads your compromesso or proposta, tells you exactly which deposit type you're signing, quotes the clause, and flags the protections you're missing — in plain English, with the questions to ask the notary. $49–79, instant.

Related guides

• What is a compromesso? Italy's binding preliminary contract, explained
• Buying property in Italy as a foreigner: the 12-point checklist
• Buying a property that was a gift: what the 2025 reform changed